Blurb..Joran doesn't have to have an explanation for anything. I suspect the body will never be found and HE knows it. No body, no crime.
Brigette, your post was chilling. I think you may have nailed it..:(
I saw a report over the weekend from a charter boat captain, saying that if they put her body in the water on the west side of the island, it would never be found because of the currents.
Well we know Croes was called. Did Daddy and Joran take her body to Croes, and then they all went up to the Natural Bridge (shark feeding area).
It is very possible that Croes may not have a car and that they had to pick him up. Croes may know the Natural Bridge area well and they needed his help. I mean if I was out to dump a body in shark feed area and if I wanted to make sure I was putting in the right spot. Maybe Croes was just simply called on the phone to get some information about the shark area.
On a small island like this Croes may be running into the law often and may have worked a deal out with the future judge in the event that Croes may have had to be in front of him in the future for some future run in with the law. Croes may be shady enough to help them out now for a future deal.
Also if they could not just throw over a cliff into the water by the shark area they may have needed Croes's water (and shark) experience as well as his connection to some type of boat.
On another note... she simply may have been dumped into a cistern or is buried under a bunch of stones and they just have not found her yet. I am still trying to figure out if they use cisterns on the island, chances are they do in rural locations on the island.