Specter is correct in saying that we need to define their rights. We are creating a new breed of prisoner, and we need to show leadership and spell out the rules.
The whole War on Terror has been a mismanaged embarassment after our initial success in Afghanistan. Iraq is taking way too long, our borders are not secure, and those prisoners in GTMO need to start getting tried and executed, or released.
'those prisoners in GTMO need to start getting tried and executed'
The only part of your post with which I agree.