Don't be a jerk. Have a LITTLE human compassion. Imagine she was your sister.
If my sister came up with a story like this I would question it. She was forcibly raped, knows who the guy is, yet she failed to report it to anyone. Any one who has ever observed young adults during spring break can attest to the wild shenanigans that goes on ,even if from close , conservative families. This girl in Aruba was from a family that was close and conservative yet she made a bad judgement call. All I am saying is that it is not unusual for young adults to have sex and then feel guilty about it later. Remember, she knows who the guy is. Would she be willing to have him charged with rape at this time or has she forgiven him?