Posted on 06/07/2005 8:14:42 PM PDT by A. Pole
For a "mature" economy with our size , none are more productive
Spot on comments
But they don't, of course. China is a developing country with enormous built in demand and a still rather primitive (overall) infrastructure. It would be absurd to extrapolate that rate of growth out indefinitely. Not going to happen.
I couldn't agree with you more. That's why these discussions are so aggravating. There is no common understanding of what constitutes economic growth nor relative well-being.
Growing an economy 6 times the size of China with 70 % less people as fast as we do is a testament to our overall productivity and efficiency.
Sure, they did alright. They're not at the bottom of the list . . . yet.
But, according to a real growth in GDP all they and we did was alright. Whether the countries you're calling third world can sustain their growth or meet some undefined test for per capita well-being, wael, I'm kinda interested in knowing the answer to that puzzle myself.
For a "mature" economy with our size , none are more productive
I can't decide whether you're quibbling or tossing out the test question. :-)
Interesting discussion, though. I just wish we had some better defined frame of reference.
What this seems to say is you're not interested in comparing the growth of world economies but prefer to measure the "standard of living" of various groups within some inconvenient national border. What is the advantage in doing that?
We? I know your not talking to me. Maybe some are getting richer, but I sure am not.
China's growth rates have stayed put for nearly two decades. Any slowdown can only happen if there is a drastic worldwide decline in the demand for "Made in China" goods, or if there is political turmoil in China. As there isn't much sign of either of these happening, don't hold your breath till any of these happen.
We all like things to be different, but unfortunately, the store shelves seem to be filling with more and more Chinese-made stuff.
BTTT
This movement of the American labor force toward Third World occupations in domestic services has dire implications both for U.S. living standards and for Americas status as a superpower.
Paging Mr. Greenspan...
...and you expect Greenspan to do what? Educate a youth whose attention span is precisely calibrated to the exact length of a music video? Maybe he should raise all the Third World wages so they are competitive with wages in the U.S.? Maybe he should implement a seres of subsidies to businesses to build factories in previously abandoned industrial areas?
It's an adult world. America will either compete or perish.
There is no "free trade" with Red China!
If China were to do something (invade Taiwan, for example) and we came to Taiwan's defense by declaring war on China, what would allies like Germany, Britain, India, France, etc. think about our attacking a country that they have so much invested in?
Or, what would the large corporations of America, who have billions invested in industrial enterprises in China, do in response to our warring with China?
Wouldn't we be threatening the billions of dollars that millions of Americans have in stocks in these corporations?
What would the result of those losses to 401K's, IRA's, etc. have on our economy?
Does anyone think that the Chinese haven't thought this out?
Further, do you think the free-traders will allow us to actually war with China?
Free trade and free traitors are killing us.
Stan Roach has seconded this in a recent essay of his.
We make lots of stuff. We make construction equipment and airplanes for example. True, we don't make shoes or textiles.
So explain to me why making shoes and textiles is so essential to our national prestige and our economic success that we should tax people who produce construction equipment and airplanes to subsidize people who produce shoes and t-shirts.
There are more shoe and t-shirt manufacturers than there are heavy equipment manufacturers. They would, in theory, employ more people.
That's pretty lame. There aren't more shoe makers and t-shirt makers in the US. And I don't want to import Mexican laborers so that we can open more of that kind of business here. I'm perfectly fine with Mexico and China making shoes and t-shirts. We'll make the construction equipment, farm equipment, airplanes, and other stuff that they can't make.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.