[wideawake]

My guess: pretty blonde American teenager is trashed out of her mind at local Aruban nightclub.

Local Aruban guy chats her up, convinces her to go to a "cooler" club nearby.

She drunkenly wanders off from the group, gets groped by the Aruban guy and his friends at the local bar and demands to return to her hotel.

Along the way they have their way with her, kill her, dispose of the body and tell the cops they actually did drop her off like she requested.

The cops accept this explanation, let them go, and watch them.

[TBall]

I think she would be more likely to go somewhere with another American tourist she met. Unfortunately evil people are everywhere and young girls need to know how to limit their vulnerability.

[hosepipe]

[ Along the way they have their way with her, kill her, dispose of the body and tell the cops they actually did drop her off like she requested. ]

On the otherhand;
Did she have life insurance, with democrat parents that are having cash flow problems in their business.?.