Some days you call it an income tax, other days it's a VAT. Pick one.
Pick one?
It is both, a progressive individual income tax coupled with a subtraction method VAT. As described by it's authors and many others as well.
FLAT TAX, VAT TAX, ANYTHING BUT THAT TAX; Duke Law Magazine, Spring 96:
- "The flat tax is essentially a VAT, with a personalized element for wages. Thus, the business tax allows deduction of all purchases -- as does a VAT -- but also allows deduction of wages. The wage income that is taken out of the VAT base, however, is also taxed, but is assessed against the individual wage-earner, not against the business."
Concerning Proposals for a Flat-Rate Consumption Tax
Before the Joint Economic Committee, Statement of Robert S. McIntyre
Director, Citizens for Tax Justice May 17, 1995
- The Hall-Rabushka flat tax, and its Armey and Specter variants, would replace the current personal and corporate income taxes with a new tax that is conceptually identical to a "subtraction-method" value-added tax, a version of a national sales tax, with two major modifications: First, imports would be exempt from the flat tax, while exports would be subject to tax. Second, to mitigate the regressivity of the VAT, cash wages, pensions received and other cash earned income would be taken out of the VAT base (i.e., deducted by businesses) and taxed directly to individuals, with exemptions. Thus, structurally, the flat tax is exactly equal to a value-added tax with an import incentive, an export disincentive and a personal rebate based on a percentage of a capped amount of cash wages, pensions and other earned income.
But then you are the resident proponent and expert of VATs & Flat Tax, so you should know that well.
Which is your favorite today VAT or "Flat Tax"??
It is both, a progressive individual income tax coupled with a subtraction method VAT. As described by it's authors and many others as well.Interesting that none of your cut & pasties say that the flat tax is a "progressive individual income tax." You want to go down the list of cut & pasties till we get to one that does?