Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: floriduh voter
I don't often agree with Hentoff but I respect him for being a straight shooter. He did a great job reporting on Terri's case and did not shrink from calling it "judicial murder" (even though he caught flak for that at his own paper, the very left-wing Village Voice).

Hentoff and Ralph Nader, another left-winger who spoke out for Terri, remind us that it isn't WHO says it, it's WHAT THEY SAY. Our goal is to get at the truth. It doesn't matter who contributes to that end or where they are on the political spectrum. The only question is, "Is what they say true?"

To fix on "who" says it is the logical fallacy known as "ad hominem." The fallacy is simply that it's a diversion to discuss the messenger instead of the message. "Who" said it is irrelevant.

For instance, some of the WPPFF folks are amazingly fixated on Dr. Hammesfahr. The party line is that he wasn't really nominated for a Nobel Prize. The answer to that is, "So what?" It has absolutely nothing to do with Terri's case. It's just ad hominem, a diversion away from the questions at hand.

Not one of the doctors who decreed death for Terri spent as much as one full hour with her. Dr. Hammesfahr spent ten hours with her over three days and wrote up extensive and wonderfully clear notes on his testing. Unlike the others, he knew he was interacting with a human being, with a naturally shy young woman. He was friendly to her, he took time to get to know her, so Terri responded much better to him than she did to brusque, unsympathetic strangers like Dr. Cranford.

In other words, the death doctors botched their job and made Terri pay with her life for their own mistakes. They probably went in there with a preconceived idea that Terri was PVS. They treated her like a vegetable and surprise! she didn't respond well. So they wrote that she was PVS.

But Terri responded well to Dr. Hammesfahr, who took the trouble to treat her as a person.

61 posted on 05/19/2005 2:58:47 PM PDT by T'wit (T'wit's Second Law: Liberals are always wrong, even when they come down on both sides of the issue.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 50 | View Replies ]


To: T'wit
Terri had a very close relationship with her mom but she perked up when Attorney Gibbs visited her, responding to his voice and getting a glimpse of his features.

The judge didn't judge. They held the line.

64 posted on 05/19/2005 6:49:24 PM PDT by floriduh voter (www.terrisfight.org & www.theemppirejournal.com... The Schindlers "Never again.")
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 61 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson