Posted on 05/12/2005 1:13:16 PM PDT by Tailgunner Joe
On a reviewing stand next to Lenin's tomb, President Bush watched as goose-stepping Russian soldiers paraded by with their hammer and sickle flags. It was a surreal moment. The threat of Communism was for many decades the defining geopolitical reality of our times.
The Cold War, the Iron Curtain, the gulags, show trials, re-education camps, the specter of nuclear annihilation, duck and cover drills at school and bomb shelters were all part of it. So were our military struggles in Korea and Vietnam, in which we lost more than 54,000 and 58,000 U.S. soldiers, respectively.
Communism would bury us, the Soviet dictator haughtily proclaimed. We and other nations responded with increasingly powerful arsenals. Maintaining the strongest possible military preparedness wasn't cheap, but our very existence was in jeopardy.
Mr. Bush was in Moscow for celebrations commemorating the 60th anniversary of the Allies defeating Nazi Germany. Victory over the Nazis was indispensable. They were led by a depraved monster whose crimes against humanity will never be forgotten.
That's as it should be. Schools still teach about the estimated six million Jews who died in the Holocaust. They educate children in the despotic evil of Nazism.
At the same time, it should also be remembered that Hitler, with an estimated ten million deaths attributed to him, wasn't the biggest killer of the 20th Century. He didn't even rank second.
China's Mao Zedong and Russia's Joseph Stalin are the greatest mass murderers in history. They weren't, like Hitler and his Nazis, national socialists. No, they were international socialists supposedly devoted to human liberation but in fact dedicated to the extermination of anyone deviating an iota from the often changing party line.
The authoritative "Black Book of Communism — Crimes, Terror and Repression" provides the following estimates:
USSR — 20 million deathsChina — 65 million deaths
Vietnam — 1 million
North Korea — 2 million deaths
Cambodia — 2 million deaths
Eastern Europe — 1 million deaths
Latin America — 150,000 deaths
Africa — 1.7 million deaths
Afghanistan — 1.5 million deaths
Man-made famines and slave labor camp confinements were common causes of death, with Lenin and Stalin killing millions that way. In Chairman Mao's China, some people were reduced to cannibalism. Other methods used by Communist tyrants were hanging, poisoning, gassing, drowning and that old standby, firing squads.
I'm glad that President Bush linked his visit to Moscow with one to Latvia. That country, along with Lithuania and Estonia, was given to Stalin, courtesy of President Franklin Roosevelt, immediately after the war. They suffered under the yoke of Soviet domination for such a long time.
Lithuania's president outlined for the Associated Press Television News the grim reality: "We are happy that the Second World War is over on May 8, but May 9 is the beginning of 50 years of slavery." Mr. Bush rightly called what happened to the Baltic nations one of the greatest wrongs of history. For millions of people around the world and since its very inception, Communism has meant only slavery, deprivation and death for the masses.
The horrors of Communism are largely overlooked. It has failed miserably everywhere it's been established, but that isn't mentioned very often.
Self-styled intellectuals at colleges and universities never tire of explaining that Communism itself is not at fault, the problem is it's never really been tried. Posters and T-shirts emblazoned with the image of Che Guevara, who helped run Castro's firing squads, are sold by capitalists who very likely would have been targeted by firing squads if they tried to operate in Cuba.
So while Nazis are roundly and fittingly condemned, Communists are often seen as simply injudicious romantics who simply made a mistake or two. Or more accurately, about 100 million if you want to count their homicidal rampages.
Communism's victims merit more than a shrug and a yawn. As we recall the defeat of the Nazis, let's keep in mind that they represented just one of mankind's two supreme evils. The other still exists, and continues its ruthless legacy, in countries like China and Cuba.
Yes they did declare war on Japan after we dropped the Bomb but ill give them credit due to there hands were full with Hitler....80% of all Germans killed were killed by Russians...
Correction on myself were killed on the Russian Front
And any Jew who was at least marginally aware of what was going on in 1930's Germany got out of Dodge (Albert Einstein being a well-known example).
But who could possibly have suspected that Stalin would have his General Staff and most of the Old Bolsheviks - loyal Communists all - wiped out as "enemies of the people"? The abject terror of meeting the same fate as Bukharin, Tukachevsky, et al. permeated all levels of Soviet society, as documented by Solzhenitsyn, Conquest, and others.
The perpetration of the absolute terror of never knowing when the axe was going to fall was, IMHO, a form of genocide far worse than anything ever seen before.
I somewhat disagree. First of all Russia had communism much longer than Germany had Fascism aka Nazism Letting it settle into the psyche of the people much longer than Hitler had time for. Im sure if hitler had waited a bit longer till lets say 1960 then it would run just as deep. But thats just how i see it.
Another way to make your point:
Nazism took over the society and used it for its own purposes. As long as groups or classes or institutions didn't threaten their control, the Nazis left them more or less alone (as long as they didn't have the misfortune of being racial enemies).
Communism requires a much more thorough control of society to work, even to work poorly. Every single institution and group has to be remodeled.
As Solzhenitsyn said, communism turned the Russian aquarium into fish soup.
Anybody can make an aquarium into fish soup. Turning fish soup back into an aquarium is a good deal more difficult.
What can I say Joe, communists tried to kill me.
Forget hell!
And now a toast, "To all those, still at sea!".
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.