Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Diplomat

"Why bother, it's clear you no little about the war as is."

It's clear you do not know how to spell "know."
In any event, I know a little more than you think pal. Try me. Obviously I am generalizing, but in this forum, anything more than three sentences gets short rift and multiple head-bobs. BUt don't post links. Any monkey can do that. Be tight, concise, and with an scent of sarcastic humor and you'll be popular.


23 posted on 05/13/2005 12:12:22 PM PDT by Tulsa Ramjet (home of the free because of the brave.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 22 | View Replies ]


To: Tulsa Ramjet
treacherous winter months that turned the blitzkreig into a frozenkreig, because you guys were up against a wall, and our troops hammered them in the West, disrupted the nazi oil supplies, and...." need I go on?

Winter didn't defeat the nazis. This just isn't true. I suspect this is a hold over saying from the Napoleonic wars applied to WWII.

The majority of the killing on the Eastern front took place before D-day. By D-day, the Russians were well on their way to defeating the nazis. Also, the vast majority of the causualties for the whole war took place on the Eastern front. I disgree with the Russians on just about everything, though I respect their sacrifices and will give them credit for sharing the lions load of the fighting. I thus I honor the war dead regardless of side. I just don't believe we Americans should hog all the credit for the defeat of nazi Germany.

What oil supplies did we disrupt that was so costly to the nazi war effort?

Our destruction of Germany's industrial base was far more helpful to the Russian war effort than anything you've mentioned.

Truth is, if we never landed at D-day, the USSR would have encompassed most of Europe.

Many Americans believe that Russia would not have survived without the Lend Lease program. I too believed this for all long time. However, the Soviets manufactured almost every weapon system they used during the war. The trucks/clothing/food and planes we sent them allowed them to more quickly attack the nazi posistions and ultimately take Berlin. I do not believe it changed the outcome of the war. Germany would still have been defeated.

My opinion is that the turning point of the war was the advent of the T-34. Until this time, the Russians had no real ability to fight off the panzer divisions, nor the ability to sustain a coordinated attack. The T-34 was an excellent design for the time. I believe it was the first true slopping armor tank. It had a 76mm gun that was good enough to penetrate the frontal armor of the mark IVs and they also built these with an 84mm (83?) gun that was also very effective. But more importantly, the T-34 was a simple design and very EASY to manufacture. Thus, the soviets mass produced so many of these, it didn't really matter how many the nazi's destroyed, they couldn't stop them all.

My opinion is that the T-34 was the true war changer. Imagine how the German soldiers felt when the first encountered these tanks on the battlefield, having been invented and manufactured by these supposed sub-humans.

What do you believe to be the single most important factor in the defeat of nazi Germany?

Good catch on "know". Although correcting my spelling error doesn't support the remainder of your advice to me. Also, you might want to check posters sign-up dates with advice of this nature.

I'm a gigantic fan of Battlefield 1942. Best computer game ever imo. I can't wait for Battlefield 2 to hit the stores in July. I assume by your name you are a military man. If you like simulations, you should try this game. I am addicted. Also, they designed a free overlay to bf1942 called Desert Combat that uses modern weapons and has maps from the first Gulf War battles.

24 posted on 05/13/2005 1:14:52 PM PDT by Diplomat
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 23 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson