I just can't believe we are the only ones who have it right. I think God works in ways that our logical minds cannot even begin to fathom.
"The road to Hell is broad and wide, the road to Heaven
is long and narrow and few there will be who will find it."
But, I certainly understand your thought processes. That great theologian, Oprah Winfrey, says the same: "All paths lead to God." However, such syncretism is a lie from the pit of hell, and it smells like smoke.
That would only be logical. If God is greater than we are, then it there must necessarily be those things (I'd say the vast majority) we are simply incapable of comprehending. Admittedly, some are very uncomfortable with this idea.