[SoftballMominVA]

I'm just not seeing a real problem here. The students ate, read and lined up orderly. What would have been better? Students yelling, throwing food, cussing teachers while wearing skimpy clothing?

Sounds like a school with a clue of how to keep order and have an environment where learning can take place.

It would have been nice if the author could have stayed a full day and commented on what went on the rest of the day.

[Sam's Army]

You think they would act out that bad if allowed to talk during lunch?

Did you?

[Osage Orange]

It would have been nice if the author could have stayed a full day and commented on what went on the rest of the day.

Sorta of like....public school folks making conclusions about HS'er's after watching them play in the yard with two of their siblings?

I happen to think the letter writer was making a point...I like sarcasm, and I think the letter was dripping with it.