" Nothing can be other than that which an infinite god wants it to be."
And if God wants us to have the freedom to choose our god?
Then God must limit himself so that our decision will be apart from him. If anything is apart from a god, then the god is not infinite.
If both are true - that god is infinite but nonetheless grants us the freedom to choose our god - then god is beyond our ability to reason, which is the point I made to begin with.