[AndrewC]

Then why do you insist on bringing up a red herring?

Answer the question, is the law we are discussing unconstitutional as determined by the courts?

[ContraryMary]

Answer the question, is the law we are discussing unconstitutional as determined by the courts?

Unfortunately, with Terri's death the law is rendered moot so it's constitutionality will never be considered in court. I do think that is unfortunate, because a definitive ruling would settle the issue. As it is now, Congress can pass another law of this type again.