Posted on 03/30/2005 5:56:53 AM PST by LowCountryJoe
I rarely devote two consecutive columns to the same issue. But the tragic case of Terri Schiavo needs some additional light shed upon it.
First, the nation is wrong if it has the impression that Florida is some sort of strange beast whose footsteps are out of sync with the rest of America. Our InsiderAdvantage flash poll conducted late last week revealed that 65 percent of Floridians agreed with the court decisions not to order the reinsertion of Schiavo's feeding tube.
A more far-reaching story remains what I touched on in my last column. The emergency congressional action two weekends ago that tried to save Schiavo's life could potentially have a boomerang political effect on the White House and the Republicans in Congress. My update is that the boomerang has come whizzing back even faster than expected.
Many GOP members of Congress privately groused about being summoned back to Washington in the first place. Doubly annoying to them was that the special weekend session was convened to address an issue that both their philosophical and political guts told them was against many of their most basic Republican instincts.
By the end of last week, the level of consternation among Republicans on Capitol Hill had grown. It had become painfully clear that much of the nation felt Congress had overreached in its actions.
Even more frustrating to Republicans was the verbal beating that Florida Gov. Jeb Bush was taking from fanatical, save Schiavo activists. They urged him to have state law enforcement officers storm Schiavo's hospice and take her into custody. They even accused both President George W. Bush and Jeb Bush of not helping at all!
How absurd. The president flew back to Washington early from vacation to sign the eleventh-hour congressional bill (apparently, we now learn, against his own best instincts). And Gov. Bush used up every reasonable legal resource to save Schiavo, not to mention much of the political capital he had stored up with his GOP-dominated state legislature.
The Bush brothers fell victim to the "no-good-deed-goes-unpunished" syndrome. With self-promotional characters liked longtime "Christian activist" Randall Terry leading the right-wing media assault on the Bushes, it's becoming clearer by the day that the Schiavo situation has spilled over the margins of decent political dissent, and is now at least partly in the province of some who have little regard for the basic rule of law.
As I've said before, I'd like to see Florida legislation that specifically addresses an incapacitated or comatose person's lack of written instructions when questions of their life or death arise. Or perhaps new laws that deal with a spouse, such as Michael Schiavo, being able to hold the keys of life and death over a wife or husband, even as he or she has in essence started another family altogether.
And yes, it enrages me that this woman is literally being starved to death right before her parents' eyes.
But there remains the need to face issues like this one both creatively and calmly. The alternative is to act or speak under a spell of emotion only, even though you know a fit of indignant pique isn't going to change the final outcomes, but only draw more attention to yourself.
Jeb Bush should be hailed for his intense political and legal efforts on behalf of Schiavo and her parents. He deserves at least equal praise for displaying the sound judgment it took not overstep the boundary of his executive authority. This helped preserve the integrity and workability of Florida's constitution and legal system.
On the flip side, the GOP in Washington, D.C. has sustained a self-inflicted blow, perhaps temporary. What had been concerted action on virtually every important issue before them -- except maybe Social Security -- has now splintered.
For the past several years, Republican congressmen in Washington and legislators in many states have controlled the lawmaking reins. They have operated in a top-down, our-way-or-the-highway style that is likely to spur the kind of mini-revolt against party leadership that happens from time to time.
Rest assured there are plenty of GOP elected officials who are suddenly wondering if they are now appearing to be the party of big budgets, intervention and expansion of government power.
The Terri Schiavo tragedy may serve as a turning point in how Republicans and other conservatives react to the issues of today -- and what may be their political success or lack of it tomorrow.
With a 45 percent approval rating, it's clear that President Bush will need the help of all Republicans to redirect GOP policy initiatives. Party loyalists now need to somehow regain the high ground of preserving the Constitution and restricting the role that government plays in our lives.
Supporters of these concepts are the ones that comprise the critical "Republican base" that must be held together and energized for action -- not the Randall Terrys of the world.
Excellent column. No good deed goes unpunished. The Bush-bashing at this forum hasn't reached this level since the Buchanan wars of 2000.
Please explain this. I get the feeling you mean that no one should try and feed a woman that is being starved to death because she might choke to death?
It's a good article, but I take strong issue with the latter half. I support the way in which Congress intervened in this case. The "45%" poll number troubles me not a bit, other than how it may reflect a good deal of ignorance on the part of some of those polled.
Leaders cannot live by the poll. You all wait--if and when Republican senators do what most all believe is right, that is, end the filibuster for judicial candidates, there will be another drop in poll numbers.
People can disagree on the Schiavo case. But it is disingenuous to harp on Congress or to complain about poll numbers.
I think this situation is likely to cause a political realignment, but not necessarily to the liking of moderates. A lot of democrats don't like to see Terri dying in this manner, don't like felos coming on tv spouting about her right to die with dignity. NOBODY sees this as a death with dignity, even without the notoriety. A lot of people think to themselves, what if this were my daughter? What if I had to helplessly and hopelessly watch her fade and die?
No. This frontal assault by the judiciary will have ramifications, and I'm not totally sure what all they'll be, but it's really hard for me to imagine that those enabling her death will reap the political reward.
Now that's a very intelligent response.... NOT!
Thanks for the ping Howlin- nothing like a reality check.
So- I wonder if the Schindler's know this is how Randall Terry thinks. He and "people like him" are "here to take over"...there's a comforting thought to ponder on, eh?
Uh, she is unable to swallow. That's why the feeding tube existed in the first place.
That's obviously not the opinion of 19 courts.
"So- I wonder if the Schindler's know this is how Randall Terry thinks. He and "people like him" are "here to take over"...there's a comforting thought to ponder on, eh?
"
I doubt that the Schindlers knew anything much about Randall Terry. He offered them help (possibly not out of the pure goodness of his heart) and they took it.
Several poor decisions have been made by the Schindlers. I imagine they're overwhelmed and are not investigating everyone who pretends to support them for altruistic reasons.
Randall Terry is, IMO, an evil man.
Exactly. Just as left wing fanatics have ruined (er, further ruined) the Democratic party, so our own fanatics seek to ruin the right. They feel like they've been lurking in the shadows long enough, unappreciated and underpowered, and now seek to assert themselves as mainstream.
The problem is, they're not. Randall Terry and his band of zealots are as poisonous to conservatism as Michael Moore is to the left. We need to be able to clean house, and not let the Kook Intifada get away with portraying itself as speaking for the right. The libs failed to clean house, and now they're stuck with some really unsavory company. That should be a lesson to us, as well.
Agreed- the Schindler's have been exploited cruelly and Terry gives me chills.
Excellent synopsis of "the problem".
Dear God, a human being made that statement?
Absolutley. And the parasites like Jesse Jackson only add fuel to the flame. Jesse's not completely stupid. He gets camera time, looks like a good guy, and helps to drive a wedge in the Conservative movement. Not bad for one trip to Florida.
When it happened, she got great care and the best therapy they could find anywhere. She was taken to an excellent rehabilitation center where she was given therapy for over 3 years - far beyond the critical 3 - 12 months when recovery is determined.
He got the $ around January 1993 - after 3 years of therapy. He did not know, when the malpractice suit was started, how much Terri would recover.
Apparently so. Randall Terry is a horrid little man, who wants the United States to throw away its Constitution and be ruled by Biblical rules.
He's part of the ragtag group that call themselves Christian Reconstructionists. They're a small group, but have some pretty strange fellow travelers connected with them.
Googling "Christian Reconstructionism" is revealing.
What is frightening to me is that, by aligning himself with the Schindler tragedy, Randall Terry is attempting to mainstream what is a very, very frightening proposition. It's instructive to trot out some of his more outrageous statements.
That said, I don't think the Schindlers have a clue as to this horrid little man's true agenda.
This is shocking rhetoric, but then again I've seen FReepers threaten another with a gun....
No. It was Randall Terry.
"This is shocking rhetoric, but then again I've seen FReepers threaten another with a gun...."
Fortunately, such threats are pulled very quickly here on Free Republic. People posting such threats don't last long as members of FR.
Probably anyone who realizes she might choke to death?
So, they're worried the woman they're starving might choke to death? Oooooooooookay.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.