Posted on 03/28/2005 11:59:57 AM PST by mdittmar
U.S. Supreme Court justices questioned on Monday the need to decide the case of a Mexican on Texas' death row, after President Bush said the defendant and 50 other inmates should get new hearings because they weren't told of their right to talk to Mexican officials.
During arguments, the justices appeared inclined to avoid a decision on the merits in the case of Jose Medellin, who is on death row in Texas. He was denied the right to meet a consular officer from Mexico after his arrest for murder.
A month ago, Bush decided to comply with a World Court decision and said state courts should review the 51 cases to determine whether the violation of their rights caused them any harm at trial or at sentencing.
Although Bush called for review of the cases, he then withdrew the United States from the part of the treaty that gives the World Court enforcement authority to decide future disputes involving foreign inmates.
Justice Antonin Scalia said the issue of whether Bush had authority to require new hearings and whether the Mexicans should get any relief would be decided in the state-court proceedings. "The whole thing could go away," he said.
Other justices questioned whether the court should simply dismiss Medellin's appeal on technical grounds, or whether they should grant his request to put the case on hold while it goes back to a Texas court.
Medellin, a gang member, was sentenced to death in state court for the 1993 rape and murder of two teenage girls in Houston, Texas. The brutal killings stemmed from a gang initiation.
In a decision on March 31, 2004, the World Court in The Hague said the United States should review the cases of the 51 Mexican death-row inmates, because U.S. officials failed to tell them of their right under the Vienna Convention to promptly consult consular officers after their arrests.
Under the Vienna Convention, which the United States ratified in 1969, U.S. officials must tell foreign nationals of their right to contact their consulates after their arrest and must notify the consulate of the arrest.
A U.S. appeals court agreed with Texas state arguments that it was too late for Medellin to pursue his claim of treaty violation because he did not raise the issue at his trial.
Medellin's attorney, Donald Donovan, urged the justices to hold the case open while the Texas courts consider it.
But Justice Sandra Day O'Connor called that an "unusual request" and said she could not recall the court ever doing that. She said the more likely action would be to dismiss the case on technical grounds.
Texas Solicitor General R. Ted Cruz said Bush's decision involved "significant constitutional problems." Texas has opposed review for any of the Mexicans on its death row.
But he said the constitutional issue could be reviewed by the state courts and ultimately by the Supreme Court, a possibility that Justice Anthony Kennedy also mentioned.
Justice John Paul Stevens said the state court proceedings could make the issue moot and added the court by ruling now "may engage in a lot of useless activity."
Justice Department lawyer Michael Dreeben agreed and said the merits of the dispute may never need to be reached, depending on how the state courts rule.
I guess Terry Schiavo should have been a Mexican murder and the Supreme Court might take more interest in her.
Once again Fox tells Bush to kiss it and he jumps for it.
or jose edellin should have been 17.
If jeb ever thought about running in "08" he can write it off.
Time to call the star chamber.
"I guess Terry Schiavo should have been a Mexican murder and the Supreme Court might take more interest in her."
This has absolutely nothing to do with Terri Schiavo.
"If jeb ever thought about running in "08" he can write it off."
Jeb Bush has indicated time and time again that he has NO interest in running for President.
What the hell??? When did this happen?
Well,the President based it on the 1969 Vienna Convention,not the U.N. adopted "world court",as rooters would have us believe.
All of you are right on so far. Justice? I think not. Just dismiss a double homicide and rape of children on "technical grounds"? Who are the sickos in black robes?
Getting real tired of the Bush brothers continuously bowing to "courts"
Maybe we should all start wearing black robes and carrying gavels and dispensing with ludicrous legal opinions. Maybe that way we can get our country back from the Tyrants that seek to enslave us.
Either that or we'd better have another Tea party.. but instead of Tea, we need to throw the entirety of the Legislature, Executive and Judicial branch into the ocean.
Nonsense. Her case has dragged on far too long and it is time to stop pretending and let her go to the Lord.
Doesn't everything? Hasn't the descent into madness convinced you that nothing else matters?
Didn't you understand ANYTHING in the article? That is NOT what the Justices are comptemplating. It is the APPEAL which is being dismissed on a technicality. Geez, the TS madness has effected your brain it looks like.
Law? We don need no stiinking Law.
If they tried to starve him to death the liberals would scream. They would scream if someone tried to starve Charles manson to death. Creepy little sicko liberals.
Didn't you understand ANYTHING in the article? That is NOT what the Justices are comptemplating. It is the APPEAL which is being dismissed on a technicality. Geez, the TS madness has effected your brain it looks like.
TS left 15 years ago and to pretend that the shell that remains is her is absurd. How many people in Florida had their life support removed yesterday and today? Dozens? More? And why have you not heard of them and joined a mob to intimidate their hospitals?
This is an everyday occurrence some Congressman said it happens thousands of times a day in this country but lets just say hundreds to be conservative. I would not condemn my worst enemy to the existence she has had to tolerate for these fifteen years. THAT is the true inhumanity.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.