generally no.
Appeal courts only look for mistakes of law.
It also was an abuse of discretion test in this case. The lowest standard for the trial judge.
The courts have generally been "legally" correct on appeal.
I think the dissent best stated the law as it should have been done.
BEWARE THE NEW DEMOCRAT PARTY / LEFTIST TALKING POINT:
THEY ARE TRYING TO SAY THIS IS NOT A LEFT VS RIGHT DECISION.
THIS IS A LEFT VS RIGHT ISSUE.
THIS IS A LIBERAL VS CONSERVATIVE ISSUE.
(eddie whatshername on foxfriends has swallowed the coolaid on this talking point. She makes watching foxand friends difficult in the am.She is the reason I have drifted back to talk radio in the am. BTW Madcow (?) really NAILED this issue when he appeared.)