Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Garnet Dawn
Do you have the same objections to taxes on beer, wine, liquor, perfume, etc.? If not, then it seems a bit hypocritical to merely object to those on tobacco products. If you object to those taxes on other nonessential products, then why are you only carping about those on tobacco?
136 posted on 03/07/2005 6:53:32 AM PST by Lucky Dog
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 79 | View Replies ]


To: Lucky Dog
You seem to have forgotten that tobacco usage is the issue being discussed. However, just for you, here is a beautiful reply for which I cannot take credit. It answers your question perfectly.

How would you like to have your next pair of $32 shoes cost you $86 dollars? Alcoholic beverages, fast food and luxuries are next. Will we be willing to pay $25 for a Big Mac in a few years? If you don't care whether smokers are overtaxed now, it could happen!

Garnet
------------------------------------------------------

"http://www.ntxe-news.com/artman/publish/article_24105.shtml

Smokers have better things to do than pay YOUR bills...
By Dave Pickrell
Mar 5, 2005

TOP TEN REASONS EXCISE TAXES SHOULD NOT BE RAISED IN TEXAS

Our Republican controlled Texas state legislature has the school funding formula close to being right. Close, but no cigar. It has proposed a wide range of taxes that will be paid by a broad base of taxpayers so to the best of their ability no one will be crushed by their tax burden. Well except for one group...smokers. The reasons why excise tax increases of this (or any) magnitude stink are listed below. Smokers wonder when the TRUE cost of smoking on this society will ever see the light of day or have public policy based upon it?

10. Smokers have better things to do than pay YOUR bills.

9. 58% of smokers make $35,000 a year or less.

8. In order to stop kids from smoking, some say raising taxes is a good idea. That's right, punish 98% of the market, which is adults of age, to influence 2%. How about parenting skills?

7. The state of Texas already takes in $130,180 every hour on cigarette taxes now. 6. But that is nothing compared to the $3,352,320 every hour by all governments nationwide.

5. Government now makes 15 times the money on a pack of cigarettes then the tobacco companies.

4. When word of this scam gets out, thugs, loan sharks and street drug dealers will be learning from politicians on how to really perfect their craft.

3. Don't we already have major problems at our boarder with Mexico? If cigarette taxes in Texas get sky high smuggling will explode. A few hundred cartons of cigarettes along with human cargo from Mexico? You bet!

2. Put yourself in our shoes. According to a major tobacco company, at the average retail price of cigarettes, smokers pay $1.61 a pack for the product, and $1.57 in excise and state sales taxes. Since you're in our shoes, let's by a pair. Shoes that cost 32.20 on the shelf would be $63.60 retail cost after the $31.20 tax bite. This is being taxed at the same proportion as the tax level on tobacco currently.

1. If the proposed excise tax increase in Texas is approved then smokers will have to pay $2.73 tax for a product that cost $1.61. And the shoes we are walking in have a sticker price of $86.80!

Would you tolerate a tax burden like this? I didn't think so. So why is the idea still on the table? A "to the bone" chill factor this cold could change our climate in Texas.

Dave Pickrell
President and founder
Smokers Fighting Discrimination, Inc.
A not for profit organization

SFD is 100% grassroots funded.

Pickrell has been an unpaid activist for the fair treatment of smokers since 1993 and a crusader against junk science being used for public policy matters.

© Copyright 2002-2005 by North Texas e-News, llc" ___________________________________________________

Do you have the same objections to taxes on beer, wine, liquor, perfume, etc.? If not, then it seems a bit hypocritical to merely object to those on tobacco products. If you object to those taxes on other nonessential products, then why are you only carping about those on tobacco?

219 posted on 03/07/2005 6:45:56 PM PST by Garnet Dawn
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 136 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson