I somehow think that you do not like what he is saying, the gist of his message rubs you the wrong way, and you cannot respond. Therefore you are deliberatly distorting what he says, then call it absurd.
As an observer, I think the points clearly go to the Sham.
You're hardly a disinterested observer. And considering you too can't demonstrate any rationale for his assertions, I would say that you are essentially asserting your religious beliefs.