[x]

Secession probably existed as a theoretical right, the union was originally a union of largely sovereign states which voluntarily turned over certain powers to the national government voluntarily and these powers theoretically could be reclaimed by the states.

Just about anything can be right in theory or a right in theory. Theories tend to multiply and swarm around the available facts. In 1860 plenty of Americans, from the President, President-elect, and Attorney General on down assumed that unilateral secession at will was unconstitutional. Given the disagreement it would have been for the best had the Supreme Court ruled on the question, or had the states appealed to Congress for deacession, but the rush to form a new country was too great.

[xroadie]

"Theories tend to multiply and swarm around the available facts."

Such a perfect comment, and not just for this string. Is it yours? Mind if I memorize it and use it at will?