Any Louis L'Amour novel that has been made into a movie is superior to 'The Unforgiven' in our opinion!
I liked most of those westerns....(I hope you didnt mean the Sharon Stone Quick and the Dead, which was crap but the Sam Elliot TQATD was pretty good for a made for TV movie)
but in my humble opinion the best 2 westerns in the last 20 years were the 'Unforgiven' (it helps if you like dark films), and Tombstone..."why my dear, your not wearing a bustle....how lewd"
Hey...how about the original Lonesome Dove miniseries...excellent