Not many rebuttals yet at the bottom of these posts.
As you say, the posts are only opinions. But so far they have been persuasive. From their tone I would judge that all the students whose remarks I have read sound fair and reasonable and give good illustrative reasons for their judgments.
These folks so far are among the more stupid of the leftist brainwashers. The smarter ones are more subtle and careful than this. But I suppose it takes a certain directness and brutality to recruit a corps of same-thinking student radicals, such as one of these responses describes: "I was soundly ridiculed by the Professor and the core of dissenters that had developed around her."
One comment on an earlier post said that the teacher lost 3/4 of the class, driven out in disgust. But I suppose the remaining quarter had the makings of some good little storm troopers.
Coming soon, an Intermediate Writing professor who showed porn in the classroom.