Kelly had a better supporting cast. Thurman Thomas is far superior to any running back the Eagles have had the past few years.
Playing hypotheticals with teammates is ridiculous. Unless it's a blow out it comes down to maybe one play that one player makes that wins the game. It's a team sport and the QB is suppossed to be the leader of the offense. McNabb had a terrible day with all those interceptions. I'm sure he won't deny it. He's still a good player but needs to get over the hump, it's really hard to get to the superbowl.