Sucked? He threw for 380+ yards and 3 TDs. He also made a couple costly mistakes--enough to cost him a close game.
If the Pats had lost by 3, people would be berating Brady for fumbling a simple hand-off in the red zone.
3 INTs plus another that was negated by a cheap penalty. 21 incomplete passes for a 58% completion rate (Brady's was 70+ with 2 TDs, no INTs). Throwing to a covered target when he had someone wide open. Running a "no-huddle" offense that huddled before every play. A fumble that was overturned on review .... of course he's gonna get yardage when he throws the ball 50 times, but that doesn't mean he played well.