The criticism directed on this thread has everything to do with her articles. Insisting that there is an ad hominem attack going on here is the only way you pretend to offer a defense.
"The criticism directed on this thread has everything to do with her articles. Insisting that there is an ad hominem attack going on here is the only way you pretend to offer a defense."
Oh I'm not defending this article either - I thought it was lame and not up to her usual. What I'm attacking is the same handful of people who seem to have it in for Noonan and hide behind disingenuous complaints as cover. Its the same dozen or so people, seen in the last 4 Noonan-bashing threads posted withing a week of each other.
Whats the real reason you guys don't like her? Because your displeasure is WAY out of PROPORTION with anything she's written.