From what I read, they are. It's full of excuses why she must be being led astray. Perhaps she really just feels the way she feels. Perhaps she's just trying to get a rise out of you. Perhaps she's just lying for ratings' sake. But people who otherwise "love" her stuff are piling on her and that's a fact.
Rush addresing these "critics" from both sides. Nailing them RIGHTLY.
Well by that criteria, what is wrong with posters on this forum feeling the way THEY feel? If Noonan can write down her "feelings", then so can posters here.