I do like the writer's approach, though. Our folks need to simply respond to silly arguments of equivalency by suggesting that the speakers apparently don't know enough about interrogation methods to speak intelligently on the subject. They need to be dismissed for the imbeciles they are.
Bump for Heather MacDonald!
We would be two years or more ahead in the War on Terror if the Democrats hadn't decided to use it as a tool to bash the President and his cabinet during election seasons. Shameful.
As the dems continue to undermine the efforts to win the war on terror, they are handing the terrorists the tools that they need to prolong the war and cause further injury and suffering to those Americans and our allies who are directly involved in it. We all know that this is a purely political battle that the dems wage against our president and the consequences be damned. They will stop at nothing to get President Bush impeached over this whole "prisoner abuse scandal," mark my words.
When the next 9-11 occurs, this "don't scare the prisoners" crap will vanish -- at the cost of thousands of more American civilian lives.
It also relies on ignorance of the Geneva convention. Denying the detainees POW status does not leave them in limbo. There is a section in the Geneva convention outlining how to treat enemy combatants. They don't get as many perks as POWs are supposed to, but they are still covered.
That said, I'd hand them over to Israel and say "do with them what you will. Let me know what you find out."