Dale Murphy should be in.
No. Not good enough for long enough. I rate Andre Dawson ahead of Dale Murphy, but I don't think the Hawk is even quite HOF worthy. The offensive standard for OF (and 1b) is much higher than for other positions.
Alan Trammell is better than both of them - and, he was robbed of the 1987 MVP award.
If he played in NY, Boston, LA or Chicago, he'd be in for sure.
"Dale Murphy should be in."
Very good ballplayer with lots of talent.
Lifetime avg - .265
Lifetime homers 398
not seeing him as worthy of the hall (but a fine player regardless)