Hang around on FR and you will see those numbers frequently. The highest number that I have seen published at FR is 20 million illegals in this country today. The official govt number is 10 million but it is universally accepted that that is a low number. Lets split the difference and say 15 million.
Given that fake papers are easy to obtain lets say that 80% have papers, even tho I think that 80% is low. That would be 12 million paying into SS.
That is today. Go back thru time, 10-20-30-40 years ago and add them all up.
Look, discussing this with you is difficult because you are not very knowledgable. I have to spend to much time getting you up to speed, like on student visas, totalization, the illegal population, etc. Plus you go off on wild tangents and try to change the subject. Not to say that the subject of blacks and SS reform is not a worthy subject, its just not germaine.
>"Given that fake papers are easy to obtain lets say that 80% have papers, even tho I think that 80% is low. That would be 12 million paying into SS."<
Fine. So you finally admit illegals are committing FRAUD by using FAKE SS ID, SS numbers, and you don't give a royal F#*k. Fraud is a *felony*, Sunshine.
You are the waste of time, you send me links to socialist web sites with bogus titles, you lie about it, you think illegal aliens are entitled to social security, etc.
You won't read anything that contradicts your liberal/socialist point of view about the cost of illegals health care/welfare either.
Worse yet you don't give a damn about the rule of law.
see ya