You're the one with the BS cliches.
I didn't use the term "Israel based" which these NYC urbans clearly are not. Like I said, criticize a neo and get called an antisemite... They are pro-Israel, as am I, but they were not much use in helping with the 76% of US Jews who voted for the anti-Israel presidential candidate. They also got very carried away with the ideals of "hegemony" that landed us a powerful new Al Quaeda enemy in the Balkans. Don't believe me? Google up "neoconservative balkans" and enjoy the roller coaster. It's quite the eye-opener. Read how they joined up with Clintonites to bomb Kosovo. Wesley Clark. Maddie Albright. McVain. Biden.
But my other objection to the neo intellirati is that they are simply boring. They run all the conservative publishing outlets, and they all sound just alike--prissily pretentious, self-adoring Ivy League, jazz-bar latte suckups. I'm tired to death of them and all their cautious prettiness. They won't give writers like Ann Coulter any ink.
I want some new writers to write some new things. I'm sick of the Kristol/Krauthammer bunch.
You assume that they are some monolithic group acting in concert. That alone makes your analysis nonsense.