To: Lucky Dog
Gravity is subject to the identical criticism [that it is both a theory and a fact]
physicists regard gravity as both a fact and a theory. You are in error, sir:
Gravity is an observed effect or phenomenon that masses appear to be attracted to each other with the strength of that attraction varying as a function of distance. Newtons and/or Einsteins theories attempted to mathematically predict results of this effect, or fact, as well as explain how it acted in Einsteins case. No one of whom I am aware confuses the fact or phenomenon of gravity with a theory of how or why it works. [Neither Newtons nor Einsteins theories is called gravity or even the the theory of gravity by scientists or the lay public
the absolute closest I could find was a reference to Newtons Theory of Universal Gravitation in some lay literature
Einsteins is the Theory of Relativity.] Therefore, your assertion that gravity is considered both a fact and theory is a mistaken opinion.
Bad luck, you contradicted something that I didn't say. Read my posts more carefully. I said a theory of gravity had only recently been proposed, not by Newton.
815 posted on
01/07/2005 11:25:20 AM PST by
Thatcherite
(Conservative and Biblical Literalist are not synonymous)
To: Thatcherite
Gravity is subject to the identical criticism [that it is both a theory and a fact]
physicists regard gravity as both a fact and a theory
Bad luck, you contradicted something that I didn't say. Read my posts more carefully. I said a theory of gravity had only recently been proposed, not by Newton.
Sorry, please forgive my misunderstanding. I am afraid I missed your point on this post. I quoted you directly in the portion you had bold faced.
Perhaps, you could refer me to a cite wherein the word "gravity," meaning the phenomenon of apparent attraction of masses, is referenced meaning, in addition to the phenomenon, an explanation of how it works and calling it the theory of gravity. I am aware of certain postulations of unified field theory or cosmological theory wherein gravity, the observed phenomenon, is proposed to be the result of extensions of quantum theory. However, I have never read of nor heard of this or any other postulations referred to only as gravity using this single word, or the theory of gravity. However, I am more than willing to stand corrected if you can send me the reference.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson