Scripture tells us to read the Bible as the Apostles did. This means that we can't interpret the Bible any way we want. Evolution is anti-God so saying an evolutionist is as faithful makes no sense. Either you believe we were created by God in His image or not. If you don't believe God created us, how can you be faithful to him? He is no longer relevant.
My personal view is that God is the ultimate programmer. He set everything in motion at the beginning and, because He is perfect, hasn't had to goof around with His creation since.
Do you really believe that the only way to be faithful to God is by holding a belief in the literal truth of Genesis? There are billions of people out there who would disagree with you.