I don't even see why this is any kind of deal whatsoever.
The guy was a terrorist. They've been completely ignoring every 'rule in the book' as a matter of practice FOREVER.
They hide behind civilians, pretend to surrender and then fight, boobytrap corpses, target innocent Iraqi's and everyone else, they behead people for gods sake.
And now we are supposed to believe that if one of these disgusting pukes, skum of the earth get injured while trying to kill our guys, and one of them that was shot in the face a day earlier doesn't want to "trust" that he is just a good guy that somehow ended up in Fallujah after months of telegraphing the attack, after getting 'injuried' in the battle, wants to 'fake play dead'... he is supposed to be afforded all these 'rights'.
Give me a fuggen' break.. I'm with the Marine from Pittsburg, I would have shot the puke terrorits in the head... twice as well... and not even thought twice about it.
Even Amnesty International says the bad guys aren't playing by the Geneva Convention. If those anti-U.S. scum say it, then they must be playing very very dirty! Free our marine, give him back his s.a.w. & lets git 'er done!