No one deserves and education. Education should, at least, be a choice. Besides, not everyone is cut out for college. Government coerced education (indoctrination) in this country is possibly one of the worst things to happen to this fine Republic. Let's move toward a market driven education system, and the government be damned.
Some students do not deserve our gift of education. I would say then why do we have prisons. Why not extend your schooling techniques to prisons and cut off hands for stealing!
To create a society of growth one has to educate all. If you believe that each family should fork out money for thier own childs education, I hope I have enough to give my kid the best!