1912 wouldn't count. Wilson was not the sitting President. Taft was.
John Fitzgerald Kennedy
Lyndon Baines Johnson
Party: DEMOCRATIC
Home State: PR: MA; VP: TX
Electoral Votes: 303
Pop. Vote: 34,227,096 (49.7%)
Lyndon Baines
JOHNSON
Hubert Horatio Humphrey
Party: DEMOCRATIC
Home State:
.PR: TX; VP: MN
Electoral Votes: 486
Pop. Vote: 42,825,463 (60.6%)
Richard Milhous
NIXON
Spiro Theodore Agnew
Party: REPUBLICAN
Home State:
.PR: NY; VP: MD
Electoral Votes: 301
Pop. Vote: 31,710,470 (43.4%)
Richard Milhous
NIXON
Spiro Theodore Agnew
Party: REPUBLICAN
Home State:
.PR: NY; VP: MD
Electoral Votes: 520
Pop. Vote: 46,740,323 (60.3%)
James Earl
CARTER, Jr.
Walter Frederick Mondale
Party: DEMOCRATIC
Home State:
.PR: GA; VP: MN
Electoral Votes: 297
Pop. Vote: 40,830,763 (50.1%)
Ronald Wilson
REAGAN
George Herbert Walker Bush
Party: REPUBLICAN
Home State:
.PR: CA; VP: TX
Electoral Votes: 489
Pop. Vote: 43,898,770 (50.8%)
Ronald Wilson
REAGAN
George Herbert Walker Bush
Party: REPUBLICAN
Home State:
.PR: CA; VP: TX
Electoral Votes: 525
Pop. Vote: 54,451,521 (58.8%)
George Herbert Walker Bush
James Danforth Quayle
Party: REPUBLICAN
Home State: PR: TX; VP: IN
Electoral Votes: 426
Pop. Vote: 48,886,097 (53.4%)
William Jefferson Clinton
Albert Arnold Gore, Jr.
Party: DEMOCRATIC
Home State: PR: AR; VP: TN
Electoral Votes: 370
Pop. Vote: 44,909,326 (43.0%)
William Jefferson Clinton
Albert Arnold Gore, Jr.
Party: DEMOCRATIC
Home State: PR: AR; VP: TN
Electoral Votes: 379
Pop. Vote: 47,401,898 (49.2%)
George Walker Bush
Richard Bruce Cheney
Party: REPUBLICAN
Home State: PR: TX; VP: WY
Electoral Votes: 271
Pop. Vote: 50,461,092 (47.9%)