"For them to be caught so off guard is surprising to me"
You shouldn't be surprised. Dan was eagerly willing to believe forged documents fed to him by the Kerry campaign .. The MSM was willing to stop crediting Bush with states he won .. The MSM was willing to hide Kerry's true record.
THEY WANTED TO BELIEVE THE NUMBERS .. THEY BELIEVED THEIR OWN ERRONEOUS PRESS. That's why they're unfit to lead America.
"They wanted to believe" is amatuerish for professional con men like the DNC and MSM.
I'm not saying you're wrong. It just doesn't pass my own personal suspicious 'smell test'.