If it was true, the only plausible explanation would be that when he made the video tape, he blew his cover, or hiding place, and now is being tracked.
I'd love to get OBL, but I'd hate for Teresa and Maddie to be able to say "I told you so", LOL!
Of course, if the Indians arrest him or take him out, then that could be another matter.
We want to take him out with a method that at least leaves enough phyisical evidence to confirm he is actually dead. We don't want another 3+ years of Elvis Bin Laden speculation.
Or simply give them the credit (or the Pakis) and demonstrate that we do, indeed, have allies in the world. Would Sen. Kerry like to also insult the country approaching the largest population in the world?