Posted on 10/12/2004 11:32:22 PM PDT by Stoat
|
No one is suggesting that mistreating animals is acceptable.
When animals are used for necessary medical research I fully support it, as there is at present no realistic alternative (the "computer model" argument of the animal rights crowd is without valid substance).
I don't know how often animals are used for cosmetics testing anymore; I have the understanding that most major cosmetics manufacturers have loudly and proudly distanced themselves from such practices decades ago. Much of what we hear about animal testing by cosmetics firms is, I believe, propaganda put forth by the "animal rights" groups. Don't forget that cosmetics firms are usually publicly-owned, and the shareholders will definitely have a voice in how their company is run.
Most people are, I believe, compassionate toward animals and believe that they should be treated with kindness and respect whenever possible.
That being said, the frequently violent acts done by "animal rights" groups work against their stated cause. Engaging in violent criminal activity is not the way civilized human beings go about changing things. We have a set of laws in place that regulate how animals are treated, and if anyone objects to the way those laws are written there are procedures in place that allow citizens to change them.
In order to have "rights", one must be able to bear responsibility. Animals are not capable of civic responsibility, therefore they do not have "rights" in the technical sense. They do, however, deserver our kindness, protection and compassion wherever possible, and we have laws in place to assure that, including strict laws in the research arena that regulate how live animal subjects are treated.
I love guinea pigs too, but if they are being treated poorly then we must change the laws, not engage in violent behaviors or criminal activity. To do so does not put forth a reasonable argument; quite the contrary.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.