Canadian City Blocks Memorial to U.S. Draft Dodgers

REUTERS ^ | Sept 29,2004

[kingattax]

VANCOUVER, British Columbia (Reuters) - A Canadian community has blocked plans for a controversial memorial to Americans who fled to Canada to avoid the Vietnam War and U.S. military draft, officials said on Wednesday.

Peace activists wanted to build the memorial as part of a reunion celebration scheduled for 2006 in Nelson, a small city in the mountains of southeastern British Columbia, where many of the Vietnam-era draft dodgers eventually settled.

The proposal was denounced by the U.S. Veterans of Foreign Wars, and came as the issue of service in the military during Vietnam has become an emotional flashpoint in the U.S. presidential campaign.

Nelson's council passed a special resolution on Wednesday that would requires any memorial using public funds or being built on public lands to have "widespread community support."

"The Our Way Home monument does not meet this standard," the council said in a press release.

The veterans group and other U.S. critics of the plan had asked the White House to intervene, and threatened to organize an economic boycott of the Nelson area in the Kootenay Region, which has a significant tourism industry.

The Our Way Home group had already told city officials it was willing to locate the bronze sculpture somewhere else, but still planned to hold the peace gathering in July 2006.

The group said it wanted to honor both the U.S. citizens who moved to Canada, rather than serve in a war they politically opposed, and the Canadians who helped them build lives in a new country.

It has been estimated that 125,000 Americans fled to Canada to avoid Vietnam and prosecution under U.S. law, although about half returned home after President Jimmy Carter granted amnesty in 1997

[SolutionsOnly]

"The actions here are what have relevance. They did the right thing. I don't care why."

I have to disagree with that. 'Why' is important in that there's a difference in doing something because it 'is the right thing to do' - not out of fear of a penalty.

[RFEngineer]

"I have to disagree with that. 'Why' is important in that there's a difference in doing something because it 'is the right thing to do' - not out of fear of a penalty."

This is a whole city. This is politics. This is a group of people.......no, the only way to obtain meaning from this is to look at the actions. I like the actions.

If you want to continue to flog the good folks of Nelson BC who, through no fault of their own, were once infested with cowardly draft-dodging vermin, go ahead. These folks are OK in my book.

[SolutionsOnly]

I fully support the 'good folks' of Nelson, BC. The problem is either that there aren't enough of them - or that they are not being heard. Regardless, the relentless anti-Americanism flowing from Canada has seriously eroded my previously very pro-Canada stance down to a pro-Alberta stance. The rest of the country seems bent on going down the euro-socialist trail. The notion that this idea even got off the ground is disturbing. I wonder how it would have played out had Fox news not gotten ahold of the story.

[RFEngineer]

"The notion that this idea even got off the ground is disturbing"

I agree....but you can bet there were more than a couple Draftdodging Americans foisting this embarassment.

I know more about Canadian anti-Americanism than I care to admit......and will have a good set of first-hand data after I return from a wedding in BC next week. Should be amusing to see how far gone they have gotten.