Michael Medved
Medved is best for serious talk. Not the most entertaining but he is extremely knowledgable. Savage is great but he's too schizophrenic to be taken too seriously. Phil Hendrie is definitly the most entertaining though.
Yep, Medved going away, although he lacks nuance on Muslim religion and Muslim country issues. But he engages the opposing point of view, and gives it some airtime, better than anybody in the business. His mind is like a Swiss watch. Al Rantel, the hardline gay conservative, is also incredibly informed and articulate, but not so good at engaging in something of a dialog with opponents, and causing them to self shred.