The benefit of the doubt: maybe the guy didn't like getting a call from a stranger. I certainly would give out my life story to a random caller. However, I find it strange that he wouldn't give out his former name. What difference does it make? It seems like he should more secretive about his current name and address if he's worried about strangers...
I disagree. All SEALs are very aware of the "fakes" that are out there. This guy had already talked to the AP, not exactly a cold call. He knows (if he were a real SEAL), that there are questions he needs to answer. Just his Class number is sufficient to start with.
Real SEALs are not hesitant, vague, etc. in giving answers about their Class number.
There is no benefit of the doubt. The AP asking the whole world to believe this guy and we don't know who he is. Either the AP or this guy should show the proof that he is who he says he is.
You don't have to believe me, just go to the authentiseal.com site and see for yourself.