They must renounce the jihad in oath and deed. The burden of proof is on them. BTW, has any Muslim cleric issued a fatwa against bin Laden. Other than Iranian Americans, has there been any kind of Muslim rally against the Islamofascists. I recall none.
I'm not necessarily arguing with you. But it seems to me we have two ways of winning: kill every Muslim we can lay hands on or liberalize the Muslims. I've told my wife short of killing them all - which at some point becomes pretty hard core - we've got to export liberalism to these people. We've got to turn them into a bunch of college professors and artists and people who ride bikes instead of blowing up busses. Essentially, we've got to turn them into a bunch of girlie men, as Arnold would say.
This kind of apology is very liberal and leftist (remember Clinton apologizing for everything), and it's the kind of thing we need to encourage if we're going to beat them.
Or, we find this guy, stick a .357 barrel down his throat and feed him his apology in a hollow point.
I could flip a coin, but the hollow points are going to get messy.