Genghis Khan's Pen As Mighty As His Sword

Actually, the library was burned during the fighting between the Eqyptians and Romans. perhaps some remnant survived that was burned in later times. In late 48 B.C., Caesar commanded an expeditionary force to settle the civil war between Cleopatra and her brother, Ptolemy. A large fleet of war galleys was in the harbor at Alexandria, and Caesar ordered the ships burned, lest they fall into the hands of the Ptolemy's Egyptians. As the great American military biographer, Col. Theodore Ayraut Dodge noted, "It was in the conflaguration thus begun that Alexandrian library perished, togerther with many other public buildings and treasures." (Dodge, "Julius Caesar", pg. 582)

According to the link you provide, Canfora's rather lowly-rated book is merely expressing an opinion on when the library was destroyed - one that flies in the face of a mountain of evidence to the contrary. Again, perhaps some small remnant of the library survived, only to be destroyed at a later date.

Actually, no it wasn't. The library was not burned by Caesar or in Caesar's time. In Caesar's own account, the fire set among the Egyptian ships spread to the dock area, and burned "some books which chanced to be there". The Great Library was in the citadel, which is where Caesar was at the time of the fire. Since the library is referred to and continued to be used for six more centuries, claiming that Caesar burned it is difficult to reconcile.

So much for your "mountain of evidence".

As Canfora noted, after the Moslem conquest, the caliph was consulted. He sent back word that anything in the library that conflicts with the Koran should be burned, and that anything that agreed with the Koran wasn't needed either, because they had the Koran. The burning of the library's 400,000+ books (which by that time had been copied onto parchment, rather than the original papyrus, and as Canfora said, was "crawling with errors") took place in the heating systems for public baths, and took six months.

And it was Genghis Khan, the Chinese King, who burned the library at Alexandria, Egypt, detroying all those ancient documents.

Wrong.
The suspects for the destruction of the Great Library at Alexandria are Caesar, Patriarch Theophilus of Alexandria and Caliph Omar of Damascus - A Roman, a Christian, and a Moslem.

library at Alexandria

The new library at Alexandria hasn't been burned, yet.

Sigh. Most historians seem to misspell the name, Ghengis. ;-)

· join list or digest · view topics · view or post blog · bookmark · post a topic ·
	Gods Graves Glyphs	Just updating the GGG info, not sending a general distribution. To all -- please ping me to other topics which are appropriate for the GGG list. GGG managers are SunkenCiv, StayAt HomeMother, and Ernest_at_the_Beach
·Dogpile · Archaeologica · ArchaeoBlog · Archaeology · Biblical Archaeology Society · · Discover · Nat Geographic · Texas AM Anthro News · Yahoo Anthro & Archaeo · Google · · The Archaeology Channel · Excerpt, or Link only? · cgk's list of ping lists ·

The erroneous "godgravesglyphs" keyword, sorted:

Fossil trove shows life's fast recovery after big extinction [10/24/2019]
Post-apocalyptic fossils show rise of mammals after dinosaur demise [10/24/2019]
Freeper SunkenCiv [09/10/2017]
Thigh bone points to unexpectedly long survival of ancient human ancestors [12/17/2015]
Art of cheese-making is 7,500 years old [12/13/2012]
Modern culture emerged in Africa 20,000 years earlier than thought [08/04/2012]
Have scientists finally found the meteorite which set off the mysterious 1908 Tunguska catastrophe? [05/21/2012]
Tomb found at Stonehenge quarry site (Wales) [09/01/2011]
Famed fossil isn't a bird after all, analysis says (Archaeopteryx) [07/27/2011]
Evidence found in Ga. of Spanish explorer's trail- Hernando de Soto in Georgia [11/05/2009]
Are serpent men from space living among us? [10/22/2009]
Brilliant Physicists Claim the Failure of the Super Collider May Have Been Ordained by God [10/16/2009]
Farmers try to plant hemp at drug agency in Va. [10/13/2009]
Michael Moore who wrote "Stupid White Men" book with chapter- "Kill Whitey" Lives in 96% white city [09/14/2009]
Goat gives birth to a 'human'; a faun [09/09/2009]
What brand of troll am I? ZOT! [07/26/2009]
I posted a "Harry Alford - Biggest Fraud In America" thread and all I got is this ZOT! [07/26/2009]
Flumes Zoom in on Mud Rock History (could Cambrian rocks have been laid down in catastrophic flood?) [07/24/2009]
Does FR need a ZOT category? (Vanity) [07/16/2009]
SETI Invites Alien Talk ("I see unseen cosmic entities") [05/25/2009]
Building Planets: Can't Make Them, But Hurry (more sophisticated storytelling passed-off as science) [05/23/2009]
Wild, wild floods! (does growing evidence of massive regional floods point to single global flood?) [05/17/2009]
Strata Data Axes Asteroid Dinosaur Demise [05/14/2009]
A Mammoth Discovery (evidence of the flood?) [05/05/2009]
Worldwide FLOOD Worldwide EVIDENCE [05/04/2009]
First dino 'blood' extracted from ancient bone (more evidence for young earth creation!) [05/01/2009]
Are Secular Geologists Ready to Consider a Global Flood? [04/30/2009]
'Plants rights'? The latest evolutionary absurdity (G.K. Chesterton prediction coming true?) [04/30/2009]
Dumping Toxic Waste On You [04/24/2009]
Thousands Expect Apocalypse in 2012 (imspired partly by Mayan Calander) [07/06/2008]
Ancient Tablet Ignites Debate on Christianity (feed your faith not your doubts) [07/05/2008]
Ancient mega-lake discovered in Darfur [04/16/2007]
DEAD SEA SCROLLS: THREAT TO CHRISTIANITY? [02/22/2007]
Islamic Science: Neil Armstrong Proved ZOT is the Center of the World [08/07/2005]
Giant Pearl Tied to Family Squabbles [01/30/2005]
AP: Historical Christian Site Said to Be Found [Jesus's First Miracle] [12/21/2004]
Remains Of Food Shed Light On Ancient Ways [11/20/2004]
Decision Due On Hill Of Tara Motorway (Archaeology) [11/11/2004]