Replies

I have just read an article about 60th anniversary of Warsaw uprising. Below this article I found these opinions:.."warsaw ghetto uprising was a jewish undertaking. it was the jews who were in the ghetto. it was the jews who resisted the emptying of the ghetto, it was the jews who fought the nazis, it wasn't the poles.if anything the poles were more than happy to assist the nazis in murdering the jews. the ploes helped the nazis. there is a very good explanation as to why the most of the death camps were located in poland. the poles were willing participants in the murder of the jews…the poles are not innocent bystanders. they went along with the germans."..."Do this book mention the anti-semitism and crimes that the Poles commited? To easy to blame always the Krauts, when the Nazis begun to loot jewish property the Poles were eager to help them."...I've got just one question: Are these kind opinions common among the Jews ?

How would I know what “Jews” think, their thoughts aren’t heterogenious.

I don’t know what you’re reading or who you’re talking to, so there’s no was you can expect me to explain it. You should have linked the source of your complaint.

I believe the ghetto uprising, clearly a Jewish undertaking, was just over 61 years ago. You missed the 60th anniversary by over a year. Perhaps you and the article author are discussing distinctly separate Warsaw uprisings. One or both of you should be able to figure that out.

Certainly many Poles colluded with the Nazis, many resisted, and to my knowledge Poland was the only occupied government without a collaborationist government.

So what does any of this have to do with Grover Nordquist and his terrorist pals?

This is the source:

http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/ap/20040731/ap_on_re_eu/poland_warsaw_uprising_2

These opinions are #18 and #19.
It's not big deal, however I noticed that people who affirm to be Jews quite often announce similar opinions.
I really know the difference between Warsaw Ghetto Uprising in 43 and Warsaw Uprising in 44, but it seems that many people still don't know it.

I heard many times (even here on FR) about "legendary Polish antisemitism". It's true that not everyone in Poland loves Jews, but when I read this kind opinions I think that Jewish "antipolonism" is stronger than "legendary Polish antisemitism" - I don't know any Jew, so I can't check It.

I asked you about It, because I noticed that you post a lot about Israel and generally about Jews, so I thought that you are conversant person.

Neither I, nor my dictionary don't know the word "colluded".