There are a couple of alternates already:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ThreatMatrixFR/
http://www.recursiv.com/threatmatrix/index.php
Ah..thanks for the reminder about the alternative sites. I had totally forgotten about thecabal's and didn't know about the Yahoo one.
Since thecabal has already done much of what I was suggesting, maybe we should just move the discussion over to that site?
What do you guys all think? The format of thecabal's site is very similar to what I was thinking - topics divided into sections vs. one big massive thread.
Or, is there a reason we want to "hang" at FR instead?