[mrsmith]

There is so much arrogant stupidity in this one ruling, no idiot could ever be dissuaded from loving it.

[AndyJackson]

Another gutless wonder who argues by making snide comments behind people's backs. If you want to argue, state an argument that is worthy of something.

Since you think this is an outrageous decision try answering four questions:

1. What right is conferred on a detaineed by the habeas corpus privelege?

2. What does habeas corpus force the government to do that it ought not to do under these circumstances?

3. Tell me what the deleterious effect of this decision will be in the conduct of the war on terror?

4. Why is the habeas corpus privelege important? (clue Hitler's first act was to suspend habeas corpus)

Once you answer those questions with objective answers then we will have a basis for discussion.

However, I suspect like everyone else around here you do not know, which is why you and everyone else have gotten bent out of shape that the Supreme Court found the habeas corpus clause in the Constitution.