Posted on 07/03/2004 6:21:23 PM PDT by quidnunc
On the whole, I agree with Steyn. There was something larger than life about Brando, but he took his talent and wasted it. I liked On the Waterfront when it first came out, but I don't really want to see it again. I CAN'T STAND ALL THAT PORTENTOUS MUMBLING. I agree that he's good at Don Corleone, but there again, why the damned mumbling? He should've spit the cherry pits out of his mouth before he went on camera.
Steyn writes so often and so well it is hard to believe he is just one man.
Thanks Brian! BTTT
Brando was pretty good in a lot of movies. Not necessarily great, but pretty good. I have "One-Eyed Jacks" on tape and still watch it occasionally. It's still one of the best westerns of the sixties. The scene with Slim Pickens in the jail is my favorite.
Steyn let it loose. Brando was so uneven (poor script judgment at the least) that any attempt to lable him the greatest is truly unwarranted.
" Brando could have done that, if he had known what the hell he wanted to be."
I disagree - Brando did become what he wanted. He was a symbol of the irrational, self-indulgent, deconstruction of American civilization so loudly trumpted by Hollyweird.
From Last Tango in Paris (primarily memorable for making Hollyweird's first sodomy/grocery scene) to his advocacy for some sort of Native American "rights" by supporting the anarchism of AIM and Russel Means, there was always an undercurrent of perversion.
And the fact that the Indians were very acceptant of homosexuals did have a bearing on how (and why) Hollyweird flocked to their "cause".
Steyn was actually rather understated in his critique of both Hollyweird and Brando.
IMO, these were his two best roles. That and "The Wild One." In "On the Waterfront" some of the most celebrated stuff was done on the first take, i.e., the glove (it just happened, no direction from Kazan), the backseat of the cab. Those were really powerful performances
People forget that he played the same part in Streetcar on Broadway. He was the original. Now, "Guys and Dolls" and "Teahouse of the August Moon" - Some casting director wasn't thinking.
I think that about almost every actor and actress I like.
Overtly sleazy sex is what has always underlain Hollywood, so what's to hide? Well, from their perspective, at least.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.