[Windsong]

"The case against Schmidt and his mission commander, Maj. William Umbach, has been closely watched in Canada, where many were outraged by the bombing"

No amount of punishment would have been enough for Canadians. They are peaceniks, by and large. Though I am from New Orleans, my wife is from Ontario. Her entire family, save here, are mercilessly anti-american. Heaven help them if their liberal party wins AGAIN.

[Mr. Burns]

Of course, us non peacenik Americans couldn't care less if a foreign Air Force accidentally killed four of our soldiers.

[Don QN]

After looking at a lot of media reports, many of them slanted one way or the other and non of which told the whole story, these are the facts I've been able to dig out;
The Canadians -
Asked for and received permission to hold a highly unusual night live-fire exercise (in a combat area!),
Didn't have any IFF equipment, didn't ask for any and weren't offered any by U.S. forces,
Used red flares as identification (as per Canadian practice) instead of red beacons (as per U.S. practice) and didn't bother inquire of U.S. forces if this would be acceptable,
Had a problem with ricochets (buried in Candian General Baril's official report) - they were using rocket propelled grenades,
Had Canadian forces personal posted in the Kandahar Control Tower with a direct line to the exercise area but failed to cease fire for overflying aircraft in a timely manner at least once before during the exercise,
The Americans -
The Army gave permission for the exercise but didn't pass on the information to the Air Force,
The Air Force, in the preflight briefing given to Majors Umbach and Schmidt, included the possibility of a large force of Taliban near Kandahar Airport (a vital military target),
No mention of the Canadian exercise was made in the briefing,
Routed their flight over Tarnak Farms (never done during live-fire exercises in order to avoid exactly what happened),
The Pilots -
After completing their mission over Kabul were descending through 20,000 ft. ASL, had stowed their night vision equipment and turned on their navigation lights in preparation for their pending refueling,
While over Tarnak Farms (Kandahar Airport is 3300 ft. ASL and Tarnak Farms is just a couple of miles away) the Canadians resumed firing which caught the pilots completely by surprise,
After recovering from their surprise Majors Umbach and Schmidt immediately called their AWACS controllers and asked who was firing while turning off their nav lights and putting their night vision gear back on,
After calling on the Guard frequency, calling AWACS again (who was frantically trying to determine who was firing at Tarnak Farms) Manor Schmidt asked for permission to make a strafing run with his 20MM cannon to suppress the ground fire (a standard procedure),
He was denied permission and did not make the strafing run,
Major Umbach called Major Schmidt and told him to they might be friendlies,
Several minutes after the pilots' frantic initial calls AWACS still didn't know who was on the ground firing,
Major Umbach had descended and was attempting to identify the forces on the ground,
Major Schmidt observed several persons on the ground with what appeared to be artillery,
Major Umbach reported his infrared sensors showing "heat plooms" up to 10,000 ft (ASL),
[note: small arms fire is lethal up to about 2 statute miles - 10,500 ft.]
Major Umbach then reported that the ground fire was "leading him" (a standard tactic when attempting to shoot down an aircraft),
It was then that Major Schmidt called AWACS and reported he was "rolling in in self defense",
AWACS replied "roger, rolling in in self defense",
Major Schmidt reported that he had released his bomb,
AWACS replied with permission to do so,
Shortly before the bomb hit AWACS called "friendlies Kandahar - hold fire" or words to that effect,
It was too late.

Based on these facts and the qualifications of Majors Umbach and Schmidt I have to believe that what happened was a tragic accident caused by incompetence at a much higher level than the rank of Major. Major Schmidt's primary responsibility was to protect his flight leader and when Major Umbach reported that he was "being led" by the ground fire Major Schmidt acted exactly as he was supposed to. Had he not done so and Major Umbach had been shot down Major Schmidt would have been guilty of much worse.

By the way, my wife and I are from Colorado but now live in Ontario (and are dual citizens). Many Canadians feel the same way I do - don't let the biased Canadian media fool you. I also earned my PPL here. Canadian licenses are among the most respected in the world and the flight training is second to none. Finally, Heaven didn't help at all - the Liberals won again but at least won't have a majority government.