Really, this guy is a bigger boob than Falconer. He's perfectly willing to reject the facts of all of SP's self incriminating statements, his lies, the fact that he not only had the means (the newly purchased boat), motive (a lifestyle crimping baby), total lack of remorse for missing wife/child, Christmas Eve "fishing trip" to (whatta you know) exactly the same place the bodies washed up.
The idiot not only brushes all this aside but then brings up THE HOMELESS PEOPLE in the neighborhood. Well, what are the homeless folk in your area like? In mine the really top level ones have a bicycle for transportation. So a homeless person BIKED the bodies 90 miles to the bay? !!! Or, maybe they hitchhiked there with poor Laci over their shoulder.
I am so SICK of these phony devil's advocate jerks on every channel that I guess the only answer is the old off button.
Our prayer has to be that jury does not check their common sense at the court house door, and (for heaven's sake) that they watch none of these irresponsible TV gabfests.
Juror #5 is disgusting, calling pregnant women crazy (today someone had fed him a bunch of stuff how to spin it), showing obvious contempt for them. Beth Karas brought out him mentioning, for example, "financial motive" and stating that in her opinion he has been watching reports.
Scott's soul mate Justin also made the point that Scott couldn't possibly remember whether he was fishing or golfing since he had the shock of finding his wife missing. Nonsense. Scott remembered a brief reference to meringues and Amber's phone number whom he called from Laci's mother's home.