They aren't? cool! Then we should be able to run the ATF on low-lead or even blue avgas! What a savings!
I've logged every purchase of gas for the 80k miles on my 12 year old car and can easily calculate the gas mileage.
On comparable road trips higher octane (89 is recommended) consistantly has given me better gas mileage than 89 so I figure the difference in price, calculate the 5 miles a gallon difference and buy depending on what will get me further for the lowest price.
Maybe it's just my car (a Toyota six banger). I also note I get a LOT of engine knock with 89.
From experience. My car gets 10% lower gas milage with 87 (low grade in Kansas) than with 90 (mid grade). The cost is about 2% higher. 2% increase in price for 10% better milage. I must also add that when I tried premium, my milage went to crap. I am a cheap-A$$ and would not pay a nickle more for somthing if I did not have to. I have proven this over about 5 years with my car. Everytime I question it and go through a testing period, I find the same results again. This is no myth!