Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: Corin Stormhands

I've read 2 or 3 of the Potter books, to see what they were about, and also because I have a long range plan to write some kids' books in a similar genre.

I was amazed at how poorly written they were. Non-existent character development, grey in tone, no visual imagery; the characters were shallow and two dimensional. They were like dull comic books in words, and the interests of the characters were materialistic to the nth degree.

The Narnia books are lightyears ahead. The Potter books are rather nasty in subject, style and purpose.


640 posted on 06/04/2004 12:08:15 PM PDT by little jeremiah (Take Back The Rainbow! Take back the word "GAY"!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 611 | View Replies ]


To: little jeremiah; JenB; SuziQ
I was amazed at how poorly written they were. Non-existent character development, grey in tone, no visual imagery; the characters were shallow and two dimensional.

I would not compare Harry Potter to the Chronicles of Narnia or to Lord of the Rings as some have done.

But I wholeheartedly disagree with your opinion of the Potter books. And if you don't know if you've read "2 or 3" you may have "read" them, but you didn't "read" them.

645 posted on 06/04/2004 12:12:29 PM PDT by Corin Stormhands (There never was much hope...just a fool's hope...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 640 | View Replies ]

To: little jeremiah
The Narnia books are lightyears ahead. The Potter books are rather nasty in subject, style and purpose.

I tried to read the first Narnia book and found it mind numbing. I just couldn't relate to any of it and the tone was priggish, IMO. Admittedly, I was reading the book aloud and I have more difficulty following things that way. But I certainly wasn't moved to pick up the book and read it on my own.

I think the Potter books began as tremendous, "light" fun but have moved beyond that to mostly interplay between characters. The basic plot of Voldemort wanting to kill Harry becomes secondary to Ron's struggle to assert himself past the role sidekick, Neville's emerging courage, the split in the Weasley family, Harry's acceptance of his father's humanity, the whole "is Snape friend or foe?" deal, Dumbledore's shortcomings, etc. I am interested in these "people". I want to see if they live up to my expectations, or exceed them.

Chalk me up as a fan of the Ron/Hermione pairing. I don't think we've met the girl for Harry yet. And I think that Neville is poised to surprise us all.

702 posted on 06/04/2004 11:22:21 PM PDT by Dianna
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 640 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson